The “Informal” Economy
By Steve Clemens, FPC Duluth. April 14, 2006
"You can get anything you want--at Alice's Restaurant ('ceptin' Alice)"
(Arlo Guthrie)
It seems you can get anything here at FPC Duluth as well. Creativity abounds within the human spirit. One sign that human spirit has not been totally crushed within the prison is the barter economy. One of my cellmates (not a cell but a dorm--but to say roommates or dorm-mate implies one is still at college) works in the kitchen chopping veggies. So, the going price for a good-size green pepper is 3 stamps (2 stamps for a smaller one). Onions and tomatoes are a stamp apiece unless they’re bigger. Even though we were scheduled to have chicken with fried rice at the mess hall last night, he and another guy down the hall decided they'd make their own fried rice with chicken in the dorm microwave. Out came a cutting board and a makeshift "chef's knife"--a metal piece a little bigger than a credit card, which neatly chopped up the green pepper and the breaded chicken ingredients. He doesn't have much experience with doing fried rice in the microwave so several others dropped by to give him suggestions of how to do it. He used the olive oil--but didn't soak the rice in egg (not sure he had one). He forgot to add water to the rice the first time so the plastic bowl melted. The second time he got it right and with the chicken bouillon cube added by another, they said it was delicious. Ours wasn't bad either at the mess hall, but the creativity here is a wonder to behold.
Inmates who have access to the hobby craft room can make leather wallets--but the sign in the commissary says they are contraband and will be confiscated. So you can make them but can't "give" them to anyone here
because they assume you bartered them for something.
Because tobacco products were outlawed on January 1, the currency of this realm is stamps. A "book" of stamps (a page of 20 first class stamps) sells for $7.80 in the commissary. One of the guys in the room said, "Why did you pay that much? I can get you a book for $6.00 or if you buy four books at once, for $5 each." Of course, I don't have $6 or $20 in cash for the purchase. You just hand a commissary sheet to the "seller" and he fills out
what he wants worth the $6 or $20 or whatever agreed price and you buy the items for him and then make the swap. Of course all of this has to happen on the QT since it is strictly forbidden to exchange anything here. Wink, wink, nod, nod--until one of the officers decides what to enforce against whom.
Many of the longer-term inmates run some kind of "business" in order to earn money (or equivalents) for commissary purchases. Some buy a 12 pack of soda pop and then sell each can for a stamp or 2. Since each can costs the original buyer less than 29 cents, a profit can be made--especially at 2 stamps/can. The vending machine charges 75 cents each but you have to have the money credits on your card. You can “pay” (stamps) to have your boots shined and your “dress greens” pressed (ironed) for your visits. You can “buy” more stylish “cargo-style” pants for some stamps. Hair cuts at the barber shop are 6 stamps. Extra chicken from lunch, “betting in card games”, a pizza shell from the kitchen bakery all cost stamps. As cigarettes get scarcer, the price goes up- 5 stamps for a commercial one, 2 or 3 stamps for a roll-your-own type. A carton of “store-bought” cigs is now about $200. equivalent in stamps.
Letters From Prison 2006 #2- “The Christians”
“The Christians”
by Steve Clemens. FPC Duluth. Maundy Thursday. April 13,2006
"We're a Christian room," I've been told several times. It has always been accompanied with an offer or two. A guy dropped by my room today and asked how my 'first night' had been. When I told him it was my second night and it wasn't the best due to the vertical pipes running under the bedspring of my upper bunk to give added strength, he said, "We need to find you a better mattress. I'll keep an eye out for one when someone leaves."
When Christianity comes with a servant attitude, I'm much more open to any follow-up "message." My first night in the 211 ("Superior") dorm included a visit downstairs to see "the Christian brothers." I was escorted downstairs by the son of a friend from the Twin Cities. His mom told him to look me up and within a few minutes he inquired about what we might need. Donnie was out of his room but his roommate Mike (?) was in and he said "the Christians" wanted to help out with tennis shoes and shower shoes. "They've all been washed in bleach so they're safe." "You gotta wear shower shoes so your feet don't rot off in here." The shower shoes were new ("Praise the Lord," Mike added). "We live off donations. There is no charge. Of course, if you are a millionaire, you can pay us back--otherwise we're happy to get any donations people are able to make."
Tom got me a soap dish and new bar of Zest soap. He also loaned me an alarm clock when he saw I had no watch. When Donnie returned, he added a toothbrush holder, a half bottle of shampoo ("it goes farther that way—you don't mind if it is in a pill bottle, do you?" John didn't mind at all!) Some writing paper, a map of the grounds, 2 stamped envelopes. "It will hold you over until you can get money on your books" (commissary account).
And after the "service," a brief message: "There is a good Bible study in the chapel almost every evening at 6. We have a black preacher (he's good) and a great choir Wednesday evening. We have videos you can watch at the chapel. We'd love to have you join us."
Personally, I'm hesitant to go around proclaiming my identity as a "Christian." There is too much cultural and civic-religion baggage attached to it. I'd prefer to quietly share with those who may ask "for what reason I have hope within."
But at least I must tip my hat to "the Christians" who have made the transition from the “outside” to the “inside” much easier than it might have been.
by Steve Clemens. FPC Duluth. Maundy Thursday. April 13,2006
"We're a Christian room," I've been told several times. It has always been accompanied with an offer or two. A guy dropped by my room today and asked how my 'first night' had been. When I told him it was my second night and it wasn't the best due to the vertical pipes running under the bedspring of my upper bunk to give added strength, he said, "We need to find you a better mattress. I'll keep an eye out for one when someone leaves."
When Christianity comes with a servant attitude, I'm much more open to any follow-up "message." My first night in the 211 ("Superior") dorm included a visit downstairs to see "the Christian brothers." I was escorted downstairs by the son of a friend from the Twin Cities. His mom told him to look me up and within a few minutes he inquired about what we might need. Donnie was out of his room but his roommate Mike (?) was in and he said "the Christians" wanted to help out with tennis shoes and shower shoes. "They've all been washed in bleach so they're safe." "You gotta wear shower shoes so your feet don't rot off in here." The shower shoes were new ("Praise the Lord," Mike added). "We live off donations. There is no charge. Of course, if you are a millionaire, you can pay us back--otherwise we're happy to get any donations people are able to make."
Tom got me a soap dish and new bar of Zest soap. He also loaned me an alarm clock when he saw I had no watch. When Donnie returned, he added a toothbrush holder, a half bottle of shampoo ("it goes farther that way—you don't mind if it is in a pill bottle, do you?" John didn't mind at all!) Some writing paper, a map of the grounds, 2 stamped envelopes. "It will hold you over until you can get money on your books" (commissary account).
And after the "service," a brief message: "There is a good Bible study in the chapel almost every evening at 6. We have a black preacher (he's good) and a great choir Wednesday evening. We have videos you can watch at the chapel. We'd love to have you join us."
Personally, I'm hesitant to go around proclaiming my identity as a "Christian." There is too much cultural and civic-religion baggage attached to it. I'd prefer to quietly share with those who may ask "for what reason I have hope within."
But at least I must tip my hat to "the Christians" who have made the transition from the “outside” to the “inside” much easier than it might have been.
Letters From Prison 2006 #1- Holy Week in the Slammer
Holy Week in the Slammer
By Steve Clemens. FPC Duluth. April 13, 2006
Maundy Thursday 5 am, 2006
"Woke up this morning with my mind and it was stayed on Jesus." John [LaForge] went to the "Protestant" Wed. evening service because he was told they have a great choir. When they whipped into the great Negro Spiritual "Woke up this Morning," John was greatly disappointed that the refrain was just "stayed on Jesus" rather than the more appropriately (and originally) "stayed on Freedom."
Like American slavery, if you can divert the captives' attention to "Jesus," more than half the battle is won for the oppressor. I've had my experience before with "jailhouse religion" and it certainly is a regular coping tool
for a certain segment here.
I chose to attend the Maundy Thursday Catholic Mass (held on Wednesday). (They did indicate the Good Friday service would actually be held on Friday rather than Thursday though.) There were about 50-60 men attending the service in the chapel. One nice touch was the reading of the Scriptures (and some of the liturgical prayers) in both English and Spanish. I was told that Sister Timothy, a feisty old nun (from the St. Scholastica community) comes on Wednesdays and I wanted to meet her.
Typical of the tradition, the biblical passages read were the Passover/Exodus story followed by Paul's account of the last supper and John's account of the foot washing. With two basins on the altar area, I got my hopes up that the Priest was actually going to wash the feet of we convicts--or at least symbolically pick out the inmate with the most amount of time on his sentence and wash his feet. Wouldn't that have sent a clear Gospel message! However, alas, it was not to be. In an ironically creative twist, we were told we were welcomed to participate in a symbolic "hand washing" in which the good sister and the priest stood before two lines of
inmates and rubbed our hands in the basin water and then the inmate ahead of us dried our hands and then we took the towel and dried the following man's hands.
It wasn't until after the service that I realized the irony. Although it is almost certainly specious historically (Pontius Pilate was removed from his position by the Romans because of his excessive cruelty), the biblical
tradition has the Last Supper followed by Jesus' arrest and Pilate "washing his hands" of the whole messy matter of the kangaroo court and Jesus’ subsequent execution.
How does the church continue to "wash her hands" when Christ is re-crucified every day in the crushing of hopes and spirits within the prison walls? When we were handed the wafer--"the Body of Christ" during the Eucharist which followed the hand washing, we, those locked up for 3 months or 15 years, are the body of Jesus here today. If only that reality could creep into our cells (actually we live in dorms) and tear down these prison walls! (Actually we just have a chain-link fence here.)
From Courtroom to Prison:
The School of the Americas Witness Continues by Steve Clemens
Trial and Sentencing.
I expected to receive the maximum sentence of six months in a Federal Prison (for nonviolent direct action at the School of the Americas facility in November). My sentence of half that amount makes me feel like I got off easy. The government prosecutors did not certify the prior arrest/conviction records of defendants, and thus could not include them for consideration at sentencing. Therefore, my life of “crime” was not in evidence, other than my “Ban and Bar Letters” for prior trips “crossing the line” at Ft. Benning, GA.
It seemed at times that Judge G. Mallon Faircloth had the Biblical disease of “a hardened heart.” For six years he has heard testimony from principled resisters about the nature of the School and about their witness acting on behalf of the victims of torture. Hearing defendants of all ages (our group ranged from 19 to 81 years old) speak from the heart about their commitment to nonviolence, only to continue to send nuns, priests, students, and others to prison must take a toll on the one’s soul.
The Idolatry of the Law.
The focus of the prosecutors was always “Did you cross the line?” rather than “Why did you cross the line?” The Government was only interested in documenting illegal presence on the base, not whether something illegal is being taught there. The Judge made a pre-trial ruling prohibiting defendants from using an International Law and/or Necessity as a defense, despite a well-reasoned thirty page brief from defendant lawyers. What would he have said if Martin Luther King or Susan B. Anthony or members of the Boston Tea Party had stood before him?
The courtroom discourse of deterrence seems to go hand-in-glove with our present national preoccupation with the efficacy of terror and torture. Our empire threatens others with nuclear weapons or economic destabilization or torture, hoping they will conform to our policy demands. Yet this fails to work against those who value freedom and conscience over intimidation and bluster. So Fr. Jerry Zawada, a Franciscan priest, was sentenced to six months in prison, and yet returned not once but twice more. The defendants were not acting on a whim; they had counted the cost carefully before deciding it was their turn to speak for those who have no voice in the policies of the empire.
One defendant recalled the defensiveness of her German cousins who lived there during the Third Reich. The guilt and shame of their silence could not be mitigated by the refrain “But we didn’t know what was really going on.” Yet there was Judge Faircloth doing his Pontius Pilate imitation, insisting that it is the Legislative and the Executive Branches of government that sets policy about the SOA. I reminded him in my statement at sentencing that “German judges were also prosecuted at the Nuremberg Tribunals for their complicity in War Crimes.” When will any branch of our government stand up and say “no torture, no rape, no disappearing, no murder” by agents of our government?
When told that one of our fellow defendants was put in the “hole” for two weeks upon arriving at federal prison because the necessary paperwork was not done at the courthouse after sentencing, and that he had to remain on his bed for seven consecutive days because his basement segregation cell was flooded, the judge replied, “I don’t tell the Bureau of Prisons how to run their prisons and they don’t tell me how to run my courtroom.” Instead of being a check and balance to the misdeeds of government, our courts are more likely to practice cowardice, silent when torture is trumpeted by the present Administration in Washington, and deaf to the Sixth Article of the U.S. Constitution which requires judges to honor International Treaties signed by our government.
Our prison sentences come less than a week after a military jury in Colorado found a U.S. Army interrogator guilty of negligent homicide in the torture and killing of a detainee in Iraq, yet decided not to jail him. Two years after Christian Peacemaking Team members reported on the torture and mistreatment of prisoners at Abu Ghraib and other Iraqi detention centers, only a handful of low-level soldiers have be prosecuted, while the architects of those policies (Donald Rumsfeld, Alberto Gonzales, John Ashcroft, and the President) are off the hook. I pray that our actions and willingness to go to prison sends a strong message to Iraqi citizens that there are some Americans who denounce the practice of torture and murder.
Focusing on Empire through the School of the Americas.
Our witness is profoundly connected to the occupation of Iraq. Meanwhile, out of the media spotlight, peace activists, union leaders, and others continue to be gunned down in Columbia, the nation that has the largest number of troops presently being trained at the SOA. Much of the recent destabilization in Haiti can also be traced to graduates of the SOA. The SOA is a symbol of an empire bent on world domination, whether it is by economic rewards and/or strangulation, mercenary armies, or direct military intervention.
How do we resist this march of the empire? If democracy depends on the “consent of the governed,” how do we withdraw that consent? Several defendants talked about “speaking truth to power” in our trial preparations, but I think we do more truth telling with our feet than with our tongues. Kathy Kelly reminds us that “what you see depends on where you stand.” When we sit in our new Federal Prison homes in the next couple of months, what we will see is the underbelly of the empire. When our nation spends in excess of $500 billion this year for the military (not counting Veterans Affairs or war-incurred national debt payments), there is no money left from the federal coffers for education, the environment, healthcare, housing, or other human needs. My protest against the SOA is also a cry of “nunca jamas!” to empire and domination.
Our witness as privilege.
I suspect there are very few other defendants who come before this judge with a roomful of supporters. I had four friends who traveled more than 1,000 miles from Minnesota to stand with me, and two more who came from West Virginia. As a wealthy, educated, healthy white male I expect to be listened to, given the benefit of the doubt. Even though I chose to represent myself in court (rejecting the fee imposed by the judge on each defendant for using an “out-of-state lawyer!), I had ready access to lawyers if I had a question. Still, being on trial at the “mercy” of the judge gives one a small taste of losing some of that control, and it will be further challenged when I enter the prison grounds. Still, I need to remember that even this loss of control is the result of a deliberate choice I made when I decided to cross the line.
On the airplane ride home from the trial (privilege again!), the pilot walked through the cabin to greet several soldiers dressed in desert fatigues returning from the war in Iraq. “Thank you for your sacrifice,” was the refrain I expect they will hear repeatedly as they try to re-assimilate into civilian life. Warriors around the world hear the same from their supporters: Nazi soldiers, Contras, Tamil Tigers, paramilitaries in Columbia, Mujahedeen. I also expect that we “prisoners of conscience” will be greeted with the same commendation when we walk out of prison. Is this a way we can continue to live vicariously through “the sacrifice” of others without getting our own hands dirty or giving up our comfort and security?
Yet those going to jail are not necessarily more committed – it is only one form of resistance. It will take the gifts and calling of all of us to shut down the SOA: people demanding their Representatives and Senators to pass HR 1217 to investigate the record of atrocities by the SOA; people in the streets attempting to disrupt “business as usual”; letters to editors and representatives; conversations with friends and family; delegations with Witness For Peace and Christian Peacemaker Teams; and other creative ways to add our “No!” to the Domination System.
Prison.
We’ve been given a gift. Many of us will be going to prison during Holy Week. Specifically, it looks as though we’ll start our sentences the day that the church commemorates Jesus’ own civil disobedience, when he “cleaned money-changers out of the Temple.” Since Judge Faircloth is choosing not to do pre sentencing investigation reports in advance on us, we are likely to spend Maundy Thursday, Good Friday, and Easter in “the Hole”. Although our “suffering” will be insignificant in comparison with that of the original Holy Week, or with the present day victims of those trained at the SOA, it will provide us a better context for reflection during that sacred time.
Our journey into “the belly of the beast” will also coincide with the April 15 tax frenzy. We remind friends of the cost to the taxpayers for our principled protest: as some of us will likely be headed for Penitentiary instead of work camps, the per diem expense to harbor our “criminal” consciences will be even greater. Although the waiting has been difficult for some of us, hopefully we can use these next few weeks to prepare psychically for the journey ahead. To enter prison with the knowledge and support of people world-wide is a privilege few people have, so we are cognizant of our responsibility to be present to those we meet “inside” as we together struggle to recover the soul of our nation.
My report date is April 11th. My place of service for the next three months on behalf of “those who have no voice” will be prison in Duluth. My Bureau of Prisons number is 92565-020; if you wish to send me any mail after I arrive, it can be addressed as follows:
Stephen D. Clemens 92565-020
FPC Duluth Federal Prison Camp
PO Box 1000
Duluth, MN 55814
The School of the Americas Witness Continues by Steve Clemens
Trial and Sentencing.
I expected to receive the maximum sentence of six months in a Federal Prison (for nonviolent direct action at the School of the Americas facility in November). My sentence of half that amount makes me feel like I got off easy. The government prosecutors did not certify the prior arrest/conviction records of defendants, and thus could not include them for consideration at sentencing. Therefore, my life of “crime” was not in evidence, other than my “Ban and Bar Letters” for prior trips “crossing the line” at Ft. Benning, GA.
It seemed at times that Judge G. Mallon Faircloth had the Biblical disease of “a hardened heart.” For six years he has heard testimony from principled resisters about the nature of the School and about their witness acting on behalf of the victims of torture. Hearing defendants of all ages (our group ranged from 19 to 81 years old) speak from the heart about their commitment to nonviolence, only to continue to send nuns, priests, students, and others to prison must take a toll on the one’s soul.
The Idolatry of the Law.
The focus of the prosecutors was always “Did you cross the line?” rather than “Why did you cross the line?” The Government was only interested in documenting illegal presence on the base, not whether something illegal is being taught there. The Judge made a pre-trial ruling prohibiting defendants from using an International Law and/or Necessity as a defense, despite a well-reasoned thirty page brief from defendant lawyers. What would he have said if Martin Luther King or Susan B. Anthony or members of the Boston Tea Party had stood before him?
The courtroom discourse of deterrence seems to go hand-in-glove with our present national preoccupation with the efficacy of terror and torture. Our empire threatens others with nuclear weapons or economic destabilization or torture, hoping they will conform to our policy demands. Yet this fails to work against those who value freedom and conscience over intimidation and bluster. So Fr. Jerry Zawada, a Franciscan priest, was sentenced to six months in prison, and yet returned not once but twice more. The defendants were not acting on a whim; they had counted the cost carefully before deciding it was their turn to speak for those who have no voice in the policies of the empire.
One defendant recalled the defensiveness of her German cousins who lived there during the Third Reich. The guilt and shame of their silence could not be mitigated by the refrain “But we didn’t know what was really going on.” Yet there was Judge Faircloth doing his Pontius Pilate imitation, insisting that it is the Legislative and the Executive Branches of government that sets policy about the SOA. I reminded him in my statement at sentencing that “German judges were also prosecuted at the Nuremberg Tribunals for their complicity in War Crimes.” When will any branch of our government stand up and say “no torture, no rape, no disappearing, no murder” by agents of our government?
When told that one of our fellow defendants was put in the “hole” for two weeks upon arriving at federal prison because the necessary paperwork was not done at the courthouse after sentencing, and that he had to remain on his bed for seven consecutive days because his basement segregation cell was flooded, the judge replied, “I don’t tell the Bureau of Prisons how to run their prisons and they don’t tell me how to run my courtroom.” Instead of being a check and balance to the misdeeds of government, our courts are more likely to practice cowardice, silent when torture is trumpeted by the present Administration in Washington, and deaf to the Sixth Article of the U.S. Constitution which requires judges to honor International Treaties signed by our government.
Our prison sentences come less than a week after a military jury in Colorado found a U.S. Army interrogator guilty of negligent homicide in the torture and killing of a detainee in Iraq, yet decided not to jail him. Two years after Christian Peacemaking Team members reported on the torture and mistreatment of prisoners at Abu Ghraib and other Iraqi detention centers, only a handful of low-level soldiers have be prosecuted, while the architects of those policies (Donald Rumsfeld, Alberto Gonzales, John Ashcroft, and the President) are off the hook. I pray that our actions and willingness to go to prison sends a strong message to Iraqi citizens that there are some Americans who denounce the practice of torture and murder.
Focusing on Empire through the School of the Americas.
Our witness is profoundly connected to the occupation of Iraq. Meanwhile, out of the media spotlight, peace activists, union leaders, and others continue to be gunned down in Columbia, the nation that has the largest number of troops presently being trained at the SOA. Much of the recent destabilization in Haiti can also be traced to graduates of the SOA. The SOA is a symbol of an empire bent on world domination, whether it is by economic rewards and/or strangulation, mercenary armies, or direct military intervention.
How do we resist this march of the empire? If democracy depends on the “consent of the governed,” how do we withdraw that consent? Several defendants talked about “speaking truth to power” in our trial preparations, but I think we do more truth telling with our feet than with our tongues. Kathy Kelly reminds us that “what you see depends on where you stand.” When we sit in our new Federal Prison homes in the next couple of months, what we will see is the underbelly of the empire. When our nation spends in excess of $500 billion this year for the military (not counting Veterans Affairs or war-incurred national debt payments), there is no money left from the federal coffers for education, the environment, healthcare, housing, or other human needs. My protest against the SOA is also a cry of “nunca jamas!” to empire and domination.
Our witness as privilege.
I suspect there are very few other defendants who come before this judge with a roomful of supporters. I had four friends who traveled more than 1,000 miles from Minnesota to stand with me, and two more who came from West Virginia. As a wealthy, educated, healthy white male I expect to be listened to, given the benefit of the doubt. Even though I chose to represent myself in court (rejecting the fee imposed by the judge on each defendant for using an “out-of-state lawyer!), I had ready access to lawyers if I had a question. Still, being on trial at the “mercy” of the judge gives one a small taste of losing some of that control, and it will be further challenged when I enter the prison grounds. Still, I need to remember that even this loss of control is the result of a deliberate choice I made when I decided to cross the line.
On the airplane ride home from the trial (privilege again!), the pilot walked through the cabin to greet several soldiers dressed in desert fatigues returning from the war in Iraq. “Thank you for your sacrifice,” was the refrain I expect they will hear repeatedly as they try to re-assimilate into civilian life. Warriors around the world hear the same from their supporters: Nazi soldiers, Contras, Tamil Tigers, paramilitaries in Columbia, Mujahedeen. I also expect that we “prisoners of conscience” will be greeted with the same commendation when we walk out of prison. Is this a way we can continue to live vicariously through “the sacrifice” of others without getting our own hands dirty or giving up our comfort and security?
Yet those going to jail are not necessarily more committed – it is only one form of resistance. It will take the gifts and calling of all of us to shut down the SOA: people demanding their Representatives and Senators to pass HR 1217 to investigate the record of atrocities by the SOA; people in the streets attempting to disrupt “business as usual”; letters to editors and representatives; conversations with friends and family; delegations with Witness For Peace and Christian Peacemaker Teams; and other creative ways to add our “No!” to the Domination System.
Prison.
We’ve been given a gift. Many of us will be going to prison during Holy Week. Specifically, it looks as though we’ll start our sentences the day that the church commemorates Jesus’ own civil disobedience, when he “cleaned money-changers out of the Temple.” Since Judge Faircloth is choosing not to do pre sentencing investigation reports in advance on us, we are likely to spend Maundy Thursday, Good Friday, and Easter in “the Hole”. Although our “suffering” will be insignificant in comparison with that of the original Holy Week, or with the present day victims of those trained at the SOA, it will provide us a better context for reflection during that sacred time.
Our journey into “the belly of the beast” will also coincide with the April 15 tax frenzy. We remind friends of the cost to the taxpayers for our principled protest: as some of us will likely be headed for Penitentiary instead of work camps, the per diem expense to harbor our “criminal” consciences will be even greater. Although the waiting has been difficult for some of us, hopefully we can use these next few weeks to prepare psychically for the journey ahead. To enter prison with the knowledge and support of people world-wide is a privilege few people have, so we are cognizant of our responsibility to be present to those we meet “inside” as we together struggle to recover the soul of our nation.
My report date is April 11th. My place of service for the next three months on behalf of “those who have no voice” will be prison in Duluth. My Bureau of Prisons number is 92565-020; if you wish to send me any mail after I arrive, it can be addressed as follows:
Stephen D. Clemens 92565-020
FPC Duluth Federal Prison Camp
PO Box 1000
Duluth, MN 55814
Take Up Your Cross and Follow Me!
Take Up Your Cross and Follow Me!
Shared Word, Community of St. Martin. 3/12/06 by Steve Clemens
Mark 8: 31-38
Jesus began to teach them that the Human One must suffer greatly and be rejected by the elders, the chief priests, and the scribes, and be killed, and rise after three days. Jesus spoke this openly. Then Peter took him aside and began to rebuke him. At this he turned around and, looking at his disciples, rebuked Peter and said, "Get behind me, Satan. You are thinking not as God does, but as human beings do."
Jesus summoned the crowd with his disciples and said to them, "Whoever wishes to come after me must deny oneself, take up ones cross, and follow me. For whoever wishes to save ones life will lose it, but whoever loses ones life for my sake and that of the gospel will save it. What profit is there for one to gain the whole world and forfeit ones life? What could one give in exchange for ones life?
Whoever is ashamed of me and of my words in this faithless and sinful generation, the Human One will be ashamed of when he comes in his Father's glory with the holy angels."
It is interesting that this same text is almost identical in all three synoptic gospels. Matthew, Mark, and Luke all saw this passage as essential to the understanding of who Jesus was and what he taught.
I wonder what Pat Robertson has to say about this text today? After publicly calling for the assassination of Venezuelan President Hugo Chavez this summer, we should note that this is NOT a call to arms but rather a call to risky nonviolent discipleship. Ever since Constantine took up the cross and proclaimed “in this sign we conquer”, some Christians have grabbed the cross by the top and sharpened the bottom to a point to make it into a sword.
I’m reminded of the old sign they used to have at the entrance to Fort Benning in the 90’s when we gathered there for the witness against the SOA- it was a dagger shaped like a cross, placed on a shield with words above it: Follow Me! In the 1980’s a small group of candlelight vigilers would take a second sign which we placed next to it which was the identical shape, size, and color but had a cross instead of a dagger. Above both signs we placed a larger inscription: CHOOSE.
My Dad has part of this scripture printed on his personal checks – the part where it says ‘for what is a man profited if he gains the whole world and loses his own soul? I can tell you that made an impression on me as I was growing up. It was one of the ways my dad “witnessed” his faith. Of course the word witness in the Greek comes from the word we today use for martyr so it, in spirit, is close to Jesus command to “take up one’s cross” and follow him. The Anabaptists used the German word Natchfolge as a central element in their understanding of the Gospel. Natchfolge meant to “follow after”. It was how the Anabaptists defined “discipleship”. When Jesus stated: If anyone wishes to come after me, Jesus means to “follow me” … or it could mean if anyone wants to come along with me. If anyone wishes – it is something one chooses to do.
Deny oneself
When the Early Christians were arrested, they were tempted to “deny Christ” to save their lives. Polycarp, among others, was given the choice to denounce Jesus and live - or be brutally executed.
Feminist theologians have wrestled with this and other texts which have been used to keep women subservient and to endure suffering. Women have frequently been told to “deny their very selves”, especially in relationship to men in the Patriarchy of both the church and society. In today’s society, the basic unit of society is the individual self. However, when Jesus spoke his “deny yourself”, it was understood more likely as renouncing one’s kinship unit. Other Gospel passages about taking up one’s cross include the admonition “whoever does not hate father and mother, wife and children, brothers and sisters, yes, and even life itself, cannot be my disciple.” Denying oneself could mean to be willing to leave the comfort and security of one’s kinship unit.
This is one of the texts that led Dietrich Bonhoeffer to talk about “the cost of discipleship.” Bonhoeffer talked about the difference between cheap grace and costly grace, citing frequently Jesus’ call to “take up the cross and follow me.”
Clarence Jordan, founder of the Koinonia Farm Community used to speak around the country. Once, in the early 60’s he was proudly shown around a large church facility with a fountain serving as the baptismal fount. Then the person giving the tour proudly pointed to the steeple and boasted “We paid $10,000 for that cross!” Clarence wryly responded, “Use ‘to be Christians could get one of them crosses for free!”
Luke’s version adds “daily” to the admonition to take up the cross. Some preachers have used the cross as a metaphor for dealing with inconveniences, sickness, having to put up with a nasty co-worker, … But the Gospel writers are not lumping all “suffering” together or even self-sacrificing in these texts because taking up one’s cross refers only to one specific type of suffering. For Jesus and his disciples, the cross was a cruel reality, not just a metaphor. The equivalent today would be to “strap yourself into the electric chair” if you want to follow me.
Jesus is saying, let the disciples take up the position of someone already condemned to death, carrying the crossbeam of ones cross to the place of execution. In those days, the upright pole of the cross was often reused many times – the crossbar is what the condemned would carry to the place of execution.
Paul picks up this theme when he writes in Galatians 2:20:
"I have been crucified with Christ and I no longer live, but Christ lives in me. The life I live in the body, I live by faith in the Son of God, who loved me and gave himself for me."
For Paul, in the act of baptism, one is symbolically “dying” (being crucified) and when one is raised up from the water, the life we now have is by God’s grace. In baptism we are choosing our own death.
Dan Berrigan comments that when one has voluntarily given up one’s life (in the act of baptism and confession of faith), there is nothing the STATE can do to threaten you – they can put you in jail but you are already dead. The state can’t kill you if you’ve already acceded to that - so one is now no longer in fear of the state’s ultimate sanction. And that is the power of Christian nonviolence. Yes, it is costly – it is not cheap grace. But it is also powerful enough to turn the world upside right.
Ched Myers writes about this passage in Binding the Strong Man – This is the central paradox of the Gospel. The threat to punish by death is the bottom line of the power of the state; fear of this threat keeps the dominant order intact. By resisting this fear and pursuing kingdom practice even at the cost of death, the disciple contributes to shattering the powers’ reign of death in history. To concede the state’s sovereignty in death is to refuse its authority in life. … Jesus has revealed that his messiahship means political confrontation with, not rehabilitation of, the imperial state. Those who wish to “come after him” will have to identify themselves with his subversive program. The stated risk is that the disciple will face the test of loyalty under interrogation by state authorities. If “self” is denied, the cross will be taken up, a metaphor for capital punishment on grounds of insurgency.
I want to share an article from a friend of mine from the Open Door Community in Atlanta:
Persecution As a Mark of Discipleship. By Ed Loring. Hospitality. Feb. 2006
There are a number of notae, or marks, of the Church. If these marks are missing, so is the gospel. There are ways to discern the presence of the Holy Spirit in the congregant life of a confessing people. Persecution is a necessary mark of the Church of Jesus Christ. Without persecution, we know that the congregation has dropped the cross and is living in collusion with the idols of death and with the domination system that killed Jesus and Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr; bombed Koinonia Partners, burned Black Churches, and threw a rock through a stained glass window of Covenant Presbyterian Church in the Buckhead neighborhood of Atlanta.
Mark is clear as he is concrete:
Then Peter spoke up, .Look, we have left everything and followed you...”Yes,” Jesus said to them, “and I tell you that anyone who leaves home or brothers or sisters or mother or father or children or fields for me and for the gospel, will receive much more in this present age. They will receive a hundred times more houses, brothers, sisters, mothers, children and fields, and persecutions as well; and in the age to come they will receive eternal life. But many who now are first will be last, and many who now are last will be first.” (Good News Bible)
In the basic outline of the Christian life, the Beatitudes, Jesus gives two out of nine of his blessings to those who are persecuted. He did this because his life was filled with conflict, rejection, bad-mouthing, and death threats all the time. He and his followers were pursued people, and Jesus knew of the necessary rent that had to be paid to live in the household of faith. Only centuries later did domestication replace persecution as a fundamental mode of the powers to keep the truth in a vessel of lies.
“Blessed are those who are persecuted for righteousness. sake, for theirs is the Beloved Community.
“Blessed are you when people revile you and persecute you and utter all kinds of evil against you falsely on my account. Rejoice and be glad, for your reward is great in heaven, for in the same way they persecuted the prophets who were before you.” (NSRV)
Without persecution, the truth becomes distorted, a half-truth. Without persecution, the Christian Church becomes like the Kiwanis Club. Without persecution, the hard road toward a narrow door becomes an 18-hole golf course: gated, segregated, and protected by moonlighting former Marines who are now minimum-wage-earning security guards.
Reinhold Niebuhr, a theologian who has taught me much, sees an irony of history in that much of human struggle and accomplishment contains the seeds of evil, or at least the unintended consequences of loss and negation.
The loss of community experienced in African American life, for instance, is a sad and unintended result of the 1964 Civil Rights Act. There is no argument here that we should return to Jim Crow or that the Civil Rights Act should not have been passed. I worked for its passage. But as the African American community becomes more like mainstream America, it is useful to ask, “How did this happen?” The Civil Rights Act mitigated the experience of persecution of African Americans. Truer for those with money, education, and bits and shreds of privilege; but shaping for all.
No longer did an African American need the unity of community for the simple acts of the Works of Mercy. Now the market, not human relationships, offered the choices. For instance, with interstate travel, Blacks could stop and eat wherever they could afford it. No need to go out of the way to eat with relatives, friends, or make arrangements through Church connections for a meal and a shower eight hours from home. No need for the pastor or deacon to help guide the travelers to a home where they could spend the night, as Quakers had done for Harriet Tubman and her fugitive bands of runaway slaves. Need to pee? Defecate? No need to stop and ask for Hospitality; just pull over at the gas station or the rest stop and pee for free with dignity!
The money economy replaced the need for community, as persecution of Black folk was mitigated as they traveled the American highways. The role of pastor, church, women’s clubs, homes, and visiting all diminished with the passage of the 1964 Civil Rights Act. The binding needs, Hospitality, and institutions - purified by fire, hate, lynching, and Jim Crow – began to slip and spin as the unity of community spilled into the mixed waters of mainline America. The Rock of the Civil Rights Movement, the Black Church and the Black Family, were less viable as Blacks, like Jesus, moved from persecution to domestication. From the revolution of values to the .I Have a Dream. of Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr.
We are called, Black and White together, within the circle of faith, to live lives of risk and courage for the Gospel. To stop the war in Iraq. To mitigate human suffering in all of its ways and means. To house the homeless, stop the death penalty, free 87% of our prisoners. We are to pick up our cross, which means to accept persecution and follow Jesus, The Human One, into conflict, persecution and suffering - such is the
rent for the joy and goodness of a shared life in the household of faith which heals and sets us free.
(Eduard-the-Agitator Loring is a partner at the Open Door Community)
Where do we see people taking up the cross today?
On Thursday, the FBI identified the body of Tom Fox of CPT in a trash dump in Baghdad, Iraq. Yet while he and three other CPTers were still missing, Michele Obed-Naar left her family in Duluth to join the team in Baghdad. She is taking up the cross to follow.
Jacob Reitan joined a group of young people on a current-day Freedom Ride, going to so-called Christian campuses around the nation to let them know that God loves gay and lesbian people- even though those colleges have banned openly-affirming GLBT students. He now faces a possible 6-month sentence for trespassing at Jerry Falwell’s college in VA. He has taken up a cross in his attempt to follow.
Taking up a “cross” might be seen when an introverted college professor takes up what others sarcastically or cynically say is a quixotic attempt to unseat an incumbent Member of Congress from his own political party because of his strong belief that the present war and occupation of Iraq is both wrong-headed as well as immoral. This risky behavior could be the taking up of the cross in an attempt to live out his commitment to follow the nonviolent Jesus.
81-year old Delmar Schwaller will report for his 2 month prison sentence during Holy Week this April for his trespass at the School of the Americas. This WWII vet has been a city council member in Appleton, WI for 10 years and has repeatedly traveled to Nicaragua to help build schools and hospitals there. He said at his trial,
"I have listened to those who have been tortured, held captive, and witnessed friends murdered. I have also read many accounts of these horrendous acts. I have lived with, talked with, and helped to alleviate some of this pain people have suffered when I do volunteer work in Central America, especially Nicaragua. My conscience tells me it is right and just, almost compelling me to act. In the year 2000 I was arrested, processed, and released with a five-year ban from entering Fort Benning. This year the five years are up and after long years of witness, prayer, and thought I crossed the line and entered the Fort Benning military base again. I have no regrets. It was the right thing to do. Pax Christi."
Is Delmar taking up a cross to follow his Lord?
Let’s take a little time to reflect on what ways we are challenged to take up the cross today- share out loud if you wish.
Shared Word, Community of St. Martin. 3/12/06 by Steve Clemens
Mark 8: 31-38
Jesus began to teach them that the Human One must suffer greatly and be rejected by the elders, the chief priests, and the scribes, and be killed, and rise after three days. Jesus spoke this openly. Then Peter took him aside and began to rebuke him. At this he turned around and, looking at his disciples, rebuked Peter and said, "Get behind me, Satan. You are thinking not as God does, but as human beings do."
Jesus summoned the crowd with his disciples and said to them, "Whoever wishes to come after me must deny oneself, take up ones cross, and follow me. For whoever wishes to save ones life will lose it, but whoever loses ones life for my sake and that of the gospel will save it. What profit is there for one to gain the whole world and forfeit ones life? What could one give in exchange for ones life?
Whoever is ashamed of me and of my words in this faithless and sinful generation, the Human One will be ashamed of when he comes in his Father's glory with the holy angels."
It is interesting that this same text is almost identical in all three synoptic gospels. Matthew, Mark, and Luke all saw this passage as essential to the understanding of who Jesus was and what he taught.
I wonder what Pat Robertson has to say about this text today? After publicly calling for the assassination of Venezuelan President Hugo Chavez this summer, we should note that this is NOT a call to arms but rather a call to risky nonviolent discipleship. Ever since Constantine took up the cross and proclaimed “in this sign we conquer”, some Christians have grabbed the cross by the top and sharpened the bottom to a point to make it into a sword.
I’m reminded of the old sign they used to have at the entrance to Fort Benning in the 90’s when we gathered there for the witness against the SOA- it was a dagger shaped like a cross, placed on a shield with words above it: Follow Me! In the 1980’s a small group of candlelight vigilers would take a second sign which we placed next to it which was the identical shape, size, and color but had a cross instead of a dagger. Above both signs we placed a larger inscription: CHOOSE.
My Dad has part of this scripture printed on his personal checks – the part where it says ‘for what is a man profited if he gains the whole world and loses his own soul? I can tell you that made an impression on me as I was growing up. It was one of the ways my dad “witnessed” his faith. Of course the word witness in the Greek comes from the word we today use for martyr so it, in spirit, is close to Jesus command to “take up one’s cross” and follow him. The Anabaptists used the German word Natchfolge as a central element in their understanding of the Gospel. Natchfolge meant to “follow after”. It was how the Anabaptists defined “discipleship”. When Jesus stated: If anyone wishes to come after me, Jesus means to “follow me” … or it could mean if anyone wants to come along with me. If anyone wishes – it is something one chooses to do.
Deny oneself
When the Early Christians were arrested, they were tempted to “deny Christ” to save their lives. Polycarp, among others, was given the choice to denounce Jesus and live - or be brutally executed.
Feminist theologians have wrestled with this and other texts which have been used to keep women subservient and to endure suffering. Women have frequently been told to “deny their very selves”, especially in relationship to men in the Patriarchy of both the church and society. In today’s society, the basic unit of society is the individual self. However, when Jesus spoke his “deny yourself”, it was understood more likely as renouncing one’s kinship unit. Other Gospel passages about taking up one’s cross include the admonition “whoever does not hate father and mother, wife and children, brothers and sisters, yes, and even life itself, cannot be my disciple.” Denying oneself could mean to be willing to leave the comfort and security of one’s kinship unit.
This is one of the texts that led Dietrich Bonhoeffer to talk about “the cost of discipleship.” Bonhoeffer talked about the difference between cheap grace and costly grace, citing frequently Jesus’ call to “take up the cross and follow me.”
Clarence Jordan, founder of the Koinonia Farm Community used to speak around the country. Once, in the early 60’s he was proudly shown around a large church facility with a fountain serving as the baptismal fount. Then the person giving the tour proudly pointed to the steeple and boasted “We paid $10,000 for that cross!” Clarence wryly responded, “Use ‘to be Christians could get one of them crosses for free!”
Luke’s version adds “daily” to the admonition to take up the cross. Some preachers have used the cross as a metaphor for dealing with inconveniences, sickness, having to put up with a nasty co-worker, … But the Gospel writers are not lumping all “suffering” together or even self-sacrificing in these texts because taking up one’s cross refers only to one specific type of suffering. For Jesus and his disciples, the cross was a cruel reality, not just a metaphor. The equivalent today would be to “strap yourself into the electric chair” if you want to follow me.
Jesus is saying, let the disciples take up the position of someone already condemned to death, carrying the crossbeam of ones cross to the place of execution. In those days, the upright pole of the cross was often reused many times – the crossbar is what the condemned would carry to the place of execution.
Paul picks up this theme when he writes in Galatians 2:20:
"I have been crucified with Christ and I no longer live, but Christ lives in me. The life I live in the body, I live by faith in the Son of God, who loved me and gave himself for me."
For Paul, in the act of baptism, one is symbolically “dying” (being crucified) and when one is raised up from the water, the life we now have is by God’s grace. In baptism we are choosing our own death.
Dan Berrigan comments that when one has voluntarily given up one’s life (in the act of baptism and confession of faith), there is nothing the STATE can do to threaten you – they can put you in jail but you are already dead. The state can’t kill you if you’ve already acceded to that - so one is now no longer in fear of the state’s ultimate sanction. And that is the power of Christian nonviolence. Yes, it is costly – it is not cheap grace. But it is also powerful enough to turn the world upside right.
Ched Myers writes about this passage in Binding the Strong Man – This is the central paradox of the Gospel. The threat to punish by death is the bottom line of the power of the state; fear of this threat keeps the dominant order intact. By resisting this fear and pursuing kingdom practice even at the cost of death, the disciple contributes to shattering the powers’ reign of death in history. To concede the state’s sovereignty in death is to refuse its authority in life. … Jesus has revealed that his messiahship means political confrontation with, not rehabilitation of, the imperial state. Those who wish to “come after him” will have to identify themselves with his subversive program. The stated risk is that the disciple will face the test of loyalty under interrogation by state authorities. If “self” is denied, the cross will be taken up, a metaphor for capital punishment on grounds of insurgency.
I want to share an article from a friend of mine from the Open Door Community in Atlanta:
Persecution As a Mark of Discipleship. By Ed Loring. Hospitality. Feb. 2006
There are a number of notae, or marks, of the Church. If these marks are missing, so is the gospel. There are ways to discern the presence of the Holy Spirit in the congregant life of a confessing people. Persecution is a necessary mark of the Church of Jesus Christ. Without persecution, we know that the congregation has dropped the cross and is living in collusion with the idols of death and with the domination system that killed Jesus and Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr; bombed Koinonia Partners, burned Black Churches, and threw a rock through a stained glass window of Covenant Presbyterian Church in the Buckhead neighborhood of Atlanta.
Mark is clear as he is concrete:
Then Peter spoke up, .Look, we have left everything and followed you...”Yes,” Jesus said to them, “and I tell you that anyone who leaves home or brothers or sisters or mother or father or children or fields for me and for the gospel, will receive much more in this present age. They will receive a hundred times more houses, brothers, sisters, mothers, children and fields, and persecutions as well; and in the age to come they will receive eternal life. But many who now are first will be last, and many who now are last will be first.” (Good News Bible)
In the basic outline of the Christian life, the Beatitudes, Jesus gives two out of nine of his blessings to those who are persecuted. He did this because his life was filled with conflict, rejection, bad-mouthing, and death threats all the time. He and his followers were pursued people, and Jesus knew of the necessary rent that had to be paid to live in the household of faith. Only centuries later did domestication replace persecution as a fundamental mode of the powers to keep the truth in a vessel of lies.
“Blessed are those who are persecuted for righteousness. sake, for theirs is the Beloved Community.
“Blessed are you when people revile you and persecute you and utter all kinds of evil against you falsely on my account. Rejoice and be glad, for your reward is great in heaven, for in the same way they persecuted the prophets who were before you.” (NSRV)
Without persecution, the truth becomes distorted, a half-truth. Without persecution, the Christian Church becomes like the Kiwanis Club. Without persecution, the hard road toward a narrow door becomes an 18-hole golf course: gated, segregated, and protected by moonlighting former Marines who are now minimum-wage-earning security guards.
Reinhold Niebuhr, a theologian who has taught me much, sees an irony of history in that much of human struggle and accomplishment contains the seeds of evil, or at least the unintended consequences of loss and negation.
The loss of community experienced in African American life, for instance, is a sad and unintended result of the 1964 Civil Rights Act. There is no argument here that we should return to Jim Crow or that the Civil Rights Act should not have been passed. I worked for its passage. But as the African American community becomes more like mainstream America, it is useful to ask, “How did this happen?” The Civil Rights Act mitigated the experience of persecution of African Americans. Truer for those with money, education, and bits and shreds of privilege; but shaping for all.
No longer did an African American need the unity of community for the simple acts of the Works of Mercy. Now the market, not human relationships, offered the choices. For instance, with interstate travel, Blacks could stop and eat wherever they could afford it. No need to go out of the way to eat with relatives, friends, or make arrangements through Church connections for a meal and a shower eight hours from home. No need for the pastor or deacon to help guide the travelers to a home where they could spend the night, as Quakers had done for Harriet Tubman and her fugitive bands of runaway slaves. Need to pee? Defecate? No need to stop and ask for Hospitality; just pull over at the gas station or the rest stop and pee for free with dignity!
The money economy replaced the need for community, as persecution of Black folk was mitigated as they traveled the American highways. The role of pastor, church, women’s clubs, homes, and visiting all diminished with the passage of the 1964 Civil Rights Act. The binding needs, Hospitality, and institutions - purified by fire, hate, lynching, and Jim Crow – began to slip and spin as the unity of community spilled into the mixed waters of mainline America. The Rock of the Civil Rights Movement, the Black Church and the Black Family, were less viable as Blacks, like Jesus, moved from persecution to domestication. From the revolution of values to the .I Have a Dream. of Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr.
We are called, Black and White together, within the circle of faith, to live lives of risk and courage for the Gospel. To stop the war in Iraq. To mitigate human suffering in all of its ways and means. To house the homeless, stop the death penalty, free 87% of our prisoners. We are to pick up our cross, which means to accept persecution and follow Jesus, The Human One, into conflict, persecution and suffering - such is the
rent for the joy and goodness of a shared life in the household of faith which heals and sets us free.
(Eduard-the-Agitator Loring is a partner at the Open Door Community)
Where do we see people taking up the cross today?
On Thursday, the FBI identified the body of Tom Fox of CPT in a trash dump in Baghdad, Iraq. Yet while he and three other CPTers were still missing, Michele Obed-Naar left her family in Duluth to join the team in Baghdad. She is taking up the cross to follow.
Jacob Reitan joined a group of young people on a current-day Freedom Ride, going to so-called Christian campuses around the nation to let them know that God loves gay and lesbian people- even though those colleges have banned openly-affirming GLBT students. He now faces a possible 6-month sentence for trespassing at Jerry Falwell’s college in VA. He has taken up a cross in his attempt to follow.
Taking up a “cross” might be seen when an introverted college professor takes up what others sarcastically or cynically say is a quixotic attempt to unseat an incumbent Member of Congress from his own political party because of his strong belief that the present war and occupation of Iraq is both wrong-headed as well as immoral. This risky behavior could be the taking up of the cross in an attempt to live out his commitment to follow the nonviolent Jesus.
81-year old Delmar Schwaller will report for his 2 month prison sentence during Holy Week this April for his trespass at the School of the Americas. This WWII vet has been a city council member in Appleton, WI for 10 years and has repeatedly traveled to Nicaragua to help build schools and hospitals there. He said at his trial,
"I have listened to those who have been tortured, held captive, and witnessed friends murdered. I have also read many accounts of these horrendous acts. I have lived with, talked with, and helped to alleviate some of this pain people have suffered when I do volunteer work in Central America, especially Nicaragua. My conscience tells me it is right and just, almost compelling me to act. In the year 2000 I was arrested, processed, and released with a five-year ban from entering Fort Benning. This year the five years are up and after long years of witness, prayer, and thought I crossed the line and entered the Fort Benning military base again. I have no regrets. It was the right thing to do. Pax Christi."
Is Delmar taking up a cross to follow his Lord?
Let’s take a little time to reflect on what ways we are challenged to take up the cross today- share out loud if you wish.
Reflections on My SOA Trespass Trial
It’s “Only” Three Months – When I Expected Six.
Steve Clemens. February 2006
When one expects to receive the maximum sentence of six months in a Federal Prison, a sentence of half that amount can make one feel like they got off easy. The government prosecutors (U.S. Army JAG Officers) made the mistake of not certifying the prior arrest/conviction records of defendants and when the SOA Watch Legal Collective attorneys objected to including them in consideration at sentencing, the Judge had little choice in sustaining their exclusion. Therefore, my life of “crime” was not in evidence other than my “Ban and Bar Letters” given to me on prior trips “crossing the line” at Ft. Benning, GA. Unbeknownst to me, my five-year ban and bar expired the night before I entered Ft. Benning this year. (I mistakenly thought it had two more days when I entered and expected to be doubly charged for trespass and violating the ban and bar.) The SOA Watch lawyers reminded the judge that to sentence someone who did not violate the ban and bar as harshly as someone who did would send a message to others that honoring the exclusion from the base was meaningless - thus my three month sentence rather than the expected six.
It seemed at times that Judge G. Mallon Faircloth had the Biblical disease of “a hardened heart”. To hear testimony now for six years from principled resisters about the nature of the School of the Americas, to hear the witness of acting on behalf of the victims, to hear defendants of all ages (our group ranged from 19 to 81 years old) speak from the heart about their commitment to nonviolence – and then to continue to send nuns, priests, students, and other community activists to prison must take a toll on the judge’s soul.
The courtroom oozed an idolatry of the Law. The focus of the prosecutors was always did you cross the line rather than why did you cross the line? The U.S. Government represented by the JAG Officers (what ever happened to the separation of powers between military and civilian courts?) was only interested in documenting one’s illegal presence on the base, not whether something illegal is being taught on base. The collusion of the Judge with the Army’s intention was clearly evidenced when the Judge made a pre-trial ruling prohibiting defendants from using International Law and/or Necessity as a defense: this ruling despite a well-reasoned thirty page brief from defendant lawyers and without any rebuttal argument submitted by the prosecution! Whenever the judge sentenced a defendant, he explained that we had broken the law – assuming automatically that it called for punishment. If Dr. King, Susan B. Anthony, Thoreau, Gandhi, or members of the Boston Tea Party were resurrected and stood before our Judge, would he repeat the mistakes of the past by sending principled resisters to prison?
The chief values exhibited in the courtroom seemed to be those of punishment and deterrence. These values seem to go hand-in-glove with our present national preoccupation with the efficacy of terror and torture. If you threaten others (with the BOMB or with economic destabilization or other weapons of policy or warfare) then hopefully they will cease doing what you dislike or begin doing what you want. Despite history as recent as our Vietnam War days, it continues to fail to work against those who value freedom, self-deterrence, or their conscience over intimidation and bluster. What does the judge do when he gives six months in prison to a Franciscan priest and he returns not just once but twice since doing that time to commit the same act again? Fr. Jerry Zawada unashamedly told the judge this is his third time crossing the line since 9/11, not waiting for the prosecutor to ask the judge to “throw the book at him”. How does one deter a principled act of conscience? These defendants were not acting on a whim or fancy, most had counted the cost for months if not years before deciding this was their turn to add their voice on behalf of those who have no voice in the policies of the empire.
One defendant recalled the defensiveness of her German cousins who lived there during the rise and reign of the Third Reich. The guilt and shame of their silence or inaction was often attempted to be mitigated by the refrain “we didn’t know what was really going on”. Instead of saying “I don’t know what the SOA/WHINSEC is doing”, Judge Faircloth does his imitation of Pontius Pilate when he “pontificates” from the bench that it is the Legislative Branch and the Executive Branch of the government that sets the policy regarding the operations of this “school of assassins” (not a term he would use) – the Judicial Branch merely upholds those laws. I reminded him in my statement at sentencing that “German judges were also prosecuted at the Nuremberg Tribunals for their complicity in War Crimes.”
Whatever happened to the concept of checks and balances that is always touted in our high school civics classes? When will any branch of our government stand up and say “no torture, no rape, no “disappearing”, no murder” by agents of our government? Like Pilate, the Judge also “wiped his hands” of any responsibility once he sends the convicted off to prison. When told a fellow defendant was “put in the hole” for two weeks upon arriving at his federal prison destination without the necessary paperwork being done at the courthouse after sentencing, and after being informed that said political prisoner had to remain on his bed for seven consecutive days because his basement segregation cell was flooded, the judge replied, “I don’t tell the Bureau of Prisons how to run their prisons and they don’t tell me how to run my courtroom”.
In recent years we’ve heard a lot about the pitfalls (or advantages) of “activist” judges or “activist” courts. In reality, instead of being a check and balance to the misdeeds of government, most courts are more likely to practice cowardice. How many courts were willing to rule that the undeclared Vietnam War was unconstitutional? Where are the courts today when torture is trumpeted by the present Administration in Washington? When will courts heed the Sixth Article of the U.S. Constitution and honor the requirements of International Treaties signed by our government and “bind all judges” in the land? Theologically, is it reasonable to expect the court, a “principality and power,” to not be fallen and in captivity to the service of death?
It is instructive to compare our trial court with another. Our prison sentences come less than a week after a military jury in Colorado found a U.S. Army interrogator guilty of negligent homicide in the torture and killing of a detainee in Iraq but decided not to jail him. I pray it is some comfort to Iraqi citizens that our actions and willingness to go to prison sends a strong message that there are some Americans who denounce our practice of torture and murder. It has been more than two years since Christian Peacemaking Team members reported on the torture and mistreatment of prisoners at Abu Ghraib and other Iraqi detention centers yet only a handful of low-level soldiers have be prosecuted allowing the upper echelon officers, Rumsfeld, Alberto Gonzales, John Ashcroft, and the President off the hook.
Some may question why we focus on the School of the Americas - isn’t that so 1980s while we need to focus our energies in stopping the occupation of Iraq? While the U.S. media focuses on Iraq (and even there usually only from the vantage point of the Green Zone), members of the peace communities, union leaders, and other progressives continue to be gunned down in Columbia, the nation that has the largest number of troops presently being trained at WHINSEC. Like the Contra campaign in the Reagan years, this war is fought for U.S. interests by proxy armies. Our alleged concern for democracy is exposed for lie it is when one looks at the present situation in Haiti. Much of the recent destabilization there can be traced to graduates of the SOA/WHINSEC or, most recently, by direct intervention of the U.S. in the ouster of its popularly elected President who was kidnapped by the U.S. with the complicity of the Canadian and French governments after a destabilization campaign orchestrated from Washington. The SOA is primarily a symbol of the larger reality of an empire bent on world domination, whether it is by economic rewards and/or strangulation, mercenary armies, or direct military intervention.
How do we resist this march of the empire? If democracy depends on the “consent of the governed,” how do we withdraw that consent? Do we stop shopping when our President calls on us to consume our way out of the post 9/11 depression? Several defendants talked about “speaking truth to power” in our trial preparations but I think we do more “truth telling” with our feet than with our tongues. Kathy Kelly (among others) reminds us that “what you see depends on where you stand”. When we sat overnight in the Muscogee County Jail, when we stand in our new Federal Prison homes in the next couple of months, what we will see is the underbelly of the empire. Our fellow defendants from the Catholic Worker movement see this reality every day on the streets of our cities. When our nation spends in excess of $500 billion this year for the military (when you add the new request for the Iraq and Afghanistan Wars into the Department of Defense budget, not counting Veterans Affairs or war-incurred national debt payments), there is no money left from the federal coffers for education, the environment, healthcare, housing, or other human needs. My protest against the SOA, while in the context of Abu Ghraib and Columbia, the anniversaries of martyrdom in Central America, is also a cry of “nunca mas!,” no more! to empire and domination.
One of the most helpful sessions of our pre-trial meetings was the discussion of privilege. I suspect there are very few other defendants who come before this judge with a roomful of supporters. I had four friends who traveled more than 1,000 miles from Minnesota to stand with me and two more who came from West Virginia. Although by far most of those arrested plea bargain and don’t go to trial, those who do rarely have the show of support we enjoyed. As a wealthy, educated, healthy white male I expect to be listened to, given the benefit of the doubt. Being on trial, at the “mercy” of the judge, gives one a small taste of losing some of that control that I so often take for granted. Even though I chose to represent myself in court (rejecting the obscene fee imposed by the judge to charge each defendant for using an “out-of-state lawyer), I had ready access to consult with any of the lawyers if I had a question. Yet from past experience I know that sense of being in control will be sharply challenged when I enter the prison grounds. Still I need to remember that even this loss of control is the result of a deliberate choice I made when I decided to cross the line.
On the airplane ride home from the trial (privilege again!), the pilot walked through the cabin to greet several soldiers dressed in desert fatigues returning from the war in Iraq. “Thank you for your sacrifice,” was the refrain I expect they will hear time-and-again as they try to re-assimilate into civilian life. I’m sure warriors around the world hear the same: Nazi soldiers, insurgents, Contras, Tamil Tigers, paramilitaries in Columbia, private “contractors” (aka mercenaries) in Iraq, Mujaheddin, the list goes on. “Thank you for your sacrifice.” I expect political prisoners or “prisoners of conscience” have been greeted with the same when they walk out the prison doors. Is it a way we can continue to live vicariously through “the sacrifice” of others without getting our own hands dirty or giving up our comfort and security?
Going to jail may be the easier route than continuing to find creative ways to resist the empire. I recall the conversation between Thoreau and Emerson – [In times like these] why are you not in jail? Those going to jail are not necessarily more committed – it is only one form of resistance. It will take the gifts and calling of all of us to shut down this symbol of a foreign policy of domination: people demanding their Representatives and Senators to past HR 1217 to investigate the record of alleged atrocities of SOA, people in the streets attempting to disrupt “business as usual”, letters to the editors, conversations with friends and family, delegations with Witness For Peace and Christian Peacemaker Teams, and other creative ways to add our “No!” to the Domination System. Can we hear the present-day voice of Jonah to our Nineveh-like empire to repent? Will we?
Steve Clemens. February 2006
When one expects to receive the maximum sentence of six months in a Federal Prison, a sentence of half that amount can make one feel like they got off easy. The government prosecutors (U.S. Army JAG Officers) made the mistake of not certifying the prior arrest/conviction records of defendants and when the SOA Watch Legal Collective attorneys objected to including them in consideration at sentencing, the Judge had little choice in sustaining their exclusion. Therefore, my life of “crime” was not in evidence other than my “Ban and Bar Letters” given to me on prior trips “crossing the line” at Ft. Benning, GA. Unbeknownst to me, my five-year ban and bar expired the night before I entered Ft. Benning this year. (I mistakenly thought it had two more days when I entered and expected to be doubly charged for trespass and violating the ban and bar.) The SOA Watch lawyers reminded the judge that to sentence someone who did not violate the ban and bar as harshly as someone who did would send a message to others that honoring the exclusion from the base was meaningless - thus my three month sentence rather than the expected six.
It seemed at times that Judge G. Mallon Faircloth had the Biblical disease of “a hardened heart”. To hear testimony now for six years from principled resisters about the nature of the School of the Americas, to hear the witness of acting on behalf of the victims, to hear defendants of all ages (our group ranged from 19 to 81 years old) speak from the heart about their commitment to nonviolence – and then to continue to send nuns, priests, students, and other community activists to prison must take a toll on the judge’s soul.
The courtroom oozed an idolatry of the Law. The focus of the prosecutors was always did you cross the line rather than why did you cross the line? The U.S. Government represented by the JAG Officers (what ever happened to the separation of powers between military and civilian courts?) was only interested in documenting one’s illegal presence on the base, not whether something illegal is being taught on base. The collusion of the Judge with the Army’s intention was clearly evidenced when the Judge made a pre-trial ruling prohibiting defendants from using International Law and/or Necessity as a defense: this ruling despite a well-reasoned thirty page brief from defendant lawyers and without any rebuttal argument submitted by the prosecution! Whenever the judge sentenced a defendant, he explained that we had broken the law – assuming automatically that it called for punishment. If Dr. King, Susan B. Anthony, Thoreau, Gandhi, or members of the Boston Tea Party were resurrected and stood before our Judge, would he repeat the mistakes of the past by sending principled resisters to prison?
The chief values exhibited in the courtroom seemed to be those of punishment and deterrence. These values seem to go hand-in-glove with our present national preoccupation with the efficacy of terror and torture. If you threaten others (with the BOMB or with economic destabilization or other weapons of policy or warfare) then hopefully they will cease doing what you dislike or begin doing what you want. Despite history as recent as our Vietnam War days, it continues to fail to work against those who value freedom, self-deterrence, or their conscience over intimidation and bluster. What does the judge do when he gives six months in prison to a Franciscan priest and he returns not just once but twice since doing that time to commit the same act again? Fr. Jerry Zawada unashamedly told the judge this is his third time crossing the line since 9/11, not waiting for the prosecutor to ask the judge to “throw the book at him”. How does one deter a principled act of conscience? These defendants were not acting on a whim or fancy, most had counted the cost for months if not years before deciding this was their turn to add their voice on behalf of those who have no voice in the policies of the empire.
One defendant recalled the defensiveness of her German cousins who lived there during the rise and reign of the Third Reich. The guilt and shame of their silence or inaction was often attempted to be mitigated by the refrain “we didn’t know what was really going on”. Instead of saying “I don’t know what the SOA/WHINSEC is doing”, Judge Faircloth does his imitation of Pontius Pilate when he “pontificates” from the bench that it is the Legislative Branch and the Executive Branch of the government that sets the policy regarding the operations of this “school of assassins” (not a term he would use) – the Judicial Branch merely upholds those laws. I reminded him in my statement at sentencing that “German judges were also prosecuted at the Nuremberg Tribunals for their complicity in War Crimes.”
Whatever happened to the concept of checks and balances that is always touted in our high school civics classes? When will any branch of our government stand up and say “no torture, no rape, no “disappearing”, no murder” by agents of our government? Like Pilate, the Judge also “wiped his hands” of any responsibility once he sends the convicted off to prison. When told a fellow defendant was “put in the hole” for two weeks upon arriving at his federal prison destination without the necessary paperwork being done at the courthouse after sentencing, and after being informed that said political prisoner had to remain on his bed for seven consecutive days because his basement segregation cell was flooded, the judge replied, “I don’t tell the Bureau of Prisons how to run their prisons and they don’t tell me how to run my courtroom”.
In recent years we’ve heard a lot about the pitfalls (or advantages) of “activist” judges or “activist” courts. In reality, instead of being a check and balance to the misdeeds of government, most courts are more likely to practice cowardice. How many courts were willing to rule that the undeclared Vietnam War was unconstitutional? Where are the courts today when torture is trumpeted by the present Administration in Washington? When will courts heed the Sixth Article of the U.S. Constitution and honor the requirements of International Treaties signed by our government and “bind all judges” in the land? Theologically, is it reasonable to expect the court, a “principality and power,” to not be fallen and in captivity to the service of death?
It is instructive to compare our trial court with another. Our prison sentences come less than a week after a military jury in Colorado found a U.S. Army interrogator guilty of negligent homicide in the torture and killing of a detainee in Iraq but decided not to jail him. I pray it is some comfort to Iraqi citizens that our actions and willingness to go to prison sends a strong message that there are some Americans who denounce our practice of torture and murder. It has been more than two years since Christian Peacemaking Team members reported on the torture and mistreatment of prisoners at Abu Ghraib and other Iraqi detention centers yet only a handful of low-level soldiers have be prosecuted allowing the upper echelon officers, Rumsfeld, Alberto Gonzales, John Ashcroft, and the President off the hook.
Some may question why we focus on the School of the Americas - isn’t that so 1980s while we need to focus our energies in stopping the occupation of Iraq? While the U.S. media focuses on Iraq (and even there usually only from the vantage point of the Green Zone), members of the peace communities, union leaders, and other progressives continue to be gunned down in Columbia, the nation that has the largest number of troops presently being trained at WHINSEC. Like the Contra campaign in the Reagan years, this war is fought for U.S. interests by proxy armies. Our alleged concern for democracy is exposed for lie it is when one looks at the present situation in Haiti. Much of the recent destabilization there can be traced to graduates of the SOA/WHINSEC or, most recently, by direct intervention of the U.S. in the ouster of its popularly elected President who was kidnapped by the U.S. with the complicity of the Canadian and French governments after a destabilization campaign orchestrated from Washington. The SOA is primarily a symbol of the larger reality of an empire bent on world domination, whether it is by economic rewards and/or strangulation, mercenary armies, or direct military intervention.
How do we resist this march of the empire? If democracy depends on the “consent of the governed,” how do we withdraw that consent? Do we stop shopping when our President calls on us to consume our way out of the post 9/11 depression? Several defendants talked about “speaking truth to power” in our trial preparations but I think we do more “truth telling” with our feet than with our tongues. Kathy Kelly (among others) reminds us that “what you see depends on where you stand”. When we sat overnight in the Muscogee County Jail, when we stand in our new Federal Prison homes in the next couple of months, what we will see is the underbelly of the empire. Our fellow defendants from the Catholic Worker movement see this reality every day on the streets of our cities. When our nation spends in excess of $500 billion this year for the military (when you add the new request for the Iraq and Afghanistan Wars into the Department of Defense budget, not counting Veterans Affairs or war-incurred national debt payments), there is no money left from the federal coffers for education, the environment, healthcare, housing, or other human needs. My protest against the SOA, while in the context of Abu Ghraib and Columbia, the anniversaries of martyrdom in Central America, is also a cry of “nunca mas!,” no more! to empire and domination.
One of the most helpful sessions of our pre-trial meetings was the discussion of privilege. I suspect there are very few other defendants who come before this judge with a roomful of supporters. I had four friends who traveled more than 1,000 miles from Minnesota to stand with me and two more who came from West Virginia. Although by far most of those arrested plea bargain and don’t go to trial, those who do rarely have the show of support we enjoyed. As a wealthy, educated, healthy white male I expect to be listened to, given the benefit of the doubt. Being on trial, at the “mercy” of the judge, gives one a small taste of losing some of that control that I so often take for granted. Even though I chose to represent myself in court (rejecting the obscene fee imposed by the judge to charge each defendant for using an “out-of-state lawyer), I had ready access to consult with any of the lawyers if I had a question. Yet from past experience I know that sense of being in control will be sharply challenged when I enter the prison grounds. Still I need to remember that even this loss of control is the result of a deliberate choice I made when I decided to cross the line.
On the airplane ride home from the trial (privilege again!), the pilot walked through the cabin to greet several soldiers dressed in desert fatigues returning from the war in Iraq. “Thank you for your sacrifice,” was the refrain I expect they will hear time-and-again as they try to re-assimilate into civilian life. I’m sure warriors around the world hear the same: Nazi soldiers, insurgents, Contras, Tamil Tigers, paramilitaries in Columbia, private “contractors” (aka mercenaries) in Iraq, Mujaheddin, the list goes on. “Thank you for your sacrifice.” I expect political prisoners or “prisoners of conscience” have been greeted with the same when they walk out the prison doors. Is it a way we can continue to live vicariously through “the sacrifice” of others without getting our own hands dirty or giving up our comfort and security?
Going to jail may be the easier route than continuing to find creative ways to resist the empire. I recall the conversation between Thoreau and Emerson – [In times like these] why are you not in jail? Those going to jail are not necessarily more committed – it is only one form of resistance. It will take the gifts and calling of all of us to shut down this symbol of a foreign policy of domination: people demanding their Representatives and Senators to past HR 1217 to investigate the record of alleged atrocities of SOA, people in the streets attempting to disrupt “business as usual”, letters to the editors, conversations with friends and family, delegations with Witness For Peace and Christian Peacemaker Teams, and other creative ways to add our “No!” to the Domination System. Can we hear the present-day voice of Jonah to our Nineveh-like empire to repent? Will we?
Trial Statement -SOA. Jan. 2006
Trial Statement of Steve Clemens. US Federal Court. January 31, 2006
On November 20, 2005 I joined more than 19,000 fellow citizens at the entrance of Fort Benning in Columbus, GA, adding my voice to the growing chorus calling for the closure of “The Western Hemisphere Institute for Security Cooperation” (WHINSEC) aka “School of the Americas” (SOA). This peaceful/prayerful witness has been taking place in November for the past 15 years to coincide with the anniversary of the martyrdom of six Jesuit priests, their housekeeper and her daughter in San Salvador in 1989. The U.N. Truth Commission set up after El Salvador’s long, bloody civil war concluded that responsibility for the assassinations of these people of faith (as well as countless others) was directed and carried out by military personnel who had been trained at the SOA before committing these murders of unarmed advocates for justice.
I had the opportunity to travel to El Salvador this past March to be present for the national recognition of the 25th anniversary of the martyrdom/assassination of the Archbishop of El Salvador, Oscar Romero. I had read several books that have been written about his life, collections of his sermons and pastoral letters, and had viewed the motion picture released about his life and death. The love of the common people for his life and witness in El Salvador gives evidence that he has become a patron saint for the church in that small Central American nation. His murder has also been determined to have been ordered by a graduate of the SOA.
The group I joined also made a pilgrimage to two other sites during our week in El Salvador besides the places where Romero and the Jesuits were killed. We traveled to the chapel in the countryside built on the site where the bodies of three nuns and a lay religious worker were hastily buried after their rape and murders in December 1989. Again, the murders and human rights abuses to Jean Donovan, Maura Clark, Ita Ford, and Dorothy Kazel were linked to graduates of this school. I prayed for forgiveness for our complicity as citizens of the nation that trained and paid for their killers. We also were blessed to spend time with the survivors of the massacre of Copapayo, a small village outside of Suchitoto. After visiting the site of the original village and the ravine/lake shoreline where more than 150 were gunned down by the Salvadoran military, we were invited to visit their new village up-lake from there to share a meal with some of the survivors. Again, these murders of the peasants was directed by, and carried out by, SOA graduates. I went to the annual vigil this year to honor their memories.
This year was the 12th year in a row that I was able to attend the annual vigil sponsored by the School of the Americas Watch. I was blessed to be able to travel and be present with members of my faith community, the Community of St. Martin, as well as my youngest son, Zach. He is morally and politically opposed to this present war and I wanted to show him that there are nonviolent ways to take a stand in the hope that he too will embrace nonviolence as a way to refuse to participate in the oppression of others. It is my hope that he is on his own journey to become a conscientious objector to the violence in our world.
As the annual litany of names of the thousands killed in Central and South America by SOA graduates was sung in the prayerful, solemn memorial remembrance, it was my intent to carry a small cross painted with the name of Monsignor Oscar Romero on to the military base and to walk toward the location of this school of torture and assassination. It was my intent to “give legs” to my prayers for peace and an end to the violent oppression that this school symbolizes. Although I was arrested by military police before I was able to reach the SOA buildings I attempted to walk as far as I was able, each step a prayer for both the victims and the perpetrators, for our governmental leaders and all of us taxpayers who are complicit in the on-going crimes committed by the product of this institution.
I came to pray for the victims of the SOA and an end to the policy that “winks” at the violations of human rights and seeks to parse the word “torture” in order to continue its use. I came to pray for forgiveness for my own complicity as a citizen of this nation which has chosen to use military force and intimidation to secure and use a disproportionate amount of the world’s resources in the face of poverty and repression of other peoples. I have committed myself to attempt to walk in the way of nonviolence as lived and taught by Jesus of Nazareth.
I do not view my act of conscience as a criminal act. Under the U.S. Constitution, Article 6, known as the “Supremacy Clause”, U.S. citizens are informed that any treaties entered into by our government become the supreme law of the land and all judges are bound by them. When the United States signed the treaty to become a member of the United Nations, the language of that treaty contained the language of the Principles of the Nuremberg Tribunal. The last of those seven principles states that “complicity with the commission of a war crime, a crime against peace, and a crime against humanity is a violation of International Law.” Respectfully, I remind the Court that German judges were prosecuted by the Nuremberg Tribunals.
The U.S. Government as a signatory to the Convention Against Torture and the Universal Declaration of Human Rights has legally committed itself to forgo the activities I believe have been taught and encouraged by The School of the Americas and its successor, WHINSEC. As such, I feel I have a moral and legal obligation under the Nuremberg Principles not to be complicit by remaining silent in the face of the atrocities committed by graduates of this military school which has promoted torture, rape, assassination, and repression of progressive peoples in Latin America over the years. I urge our national leaders to live up to both the letter and the spirit of the treaties it has not only signed but helped write. Amnesty International USA has also called for an investigation of this school.
The SOA/WHINSEC is a symbol of our national foreign policy which has led to the tortures of Iraqis at Abu Ghraib and many other prisons in Iraq, Afghanistan, Guantanamo, and many secret locations run by the CIA around the world under the misguided aim to quell “terrorism” by violence and intimidation in order that the “beneficiaries” of the American Empire can continue a standard of living at the expense of the world’s poor. The SOA continues to train military officers of Colombia who have been implicated in human rights abuses.
I went to Fort Benning and the SOA confessing my own failure to more fully follow the life and teaching of Jesus who calls us to a lifestyle of justice and compassion. My prayers and act of civil resistance to these powers of death are a small attempt to give a voice to the voiceless, to speak and act in solidarity with the victims of our national policies which are embodied in this institution which has produced so much evil over the years. I pray that this saying “NO” to the powers of death is swallowed up in the “YES” embodied in the life and teaching of Jesus and I will continue to work for a world of justice, compassion, and equal opportunity. I ask all of you to join me as you are able to work and pray to close this school and change our policy.
I wish to end on a personal note. On Monday I was seated in the rear of the courtroom in support of my friend Sam Foster. Prior to the beginning of the trials, the Court Officer/Bailiff told us, “Act like you’re in church”, informing us of the behavior he expected of those of us observing the trials. I’ve taken his instruction to heart.
Although the Court has framed this issue before us as a political one – the law does not permit “political demonstrations on a military facility”, for me, this is primarily a theological issue.
I know this is dangerous ground because much of the worst excesses in recent history have been the result of some people acting because “God (or Allah) told me to.”
For me, as one who has chosen to follow the way of a nonviolent Jesus, I resonate with the response in Christian scripture attributed to the disciples Peter and John when a conflict arose: “We must obey God rather than human authority.”
I gladly submit to whatever punishment the Court wishes to impose but wish to make it clear that my presence on the military base on November 20 was a theological statement that this precious earth entrusted to us by our Creator is not to be used to prepare for war and domination of others but rather to embrace all of life as God’s gift.
For my sentence I suggest a period of service with the Mennonite Disaster Service in the clean-up and rebuilding of areas destroyed by recent hurricanes in the southern states in lieu of sending me to prison; I will gladly make a monetary contribution to that organization in lieu of paying a fine. I am a Mennonite and a pacifist- any fine levied by the court is a tax upon my conscience and a violation of the promises given to my ancestors in 1705 when they were recruited by William Penn to help populate the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania.
[I entered a plea of Nolo Contendre (no contest) because the Judge previously ruled before trial we were not allowed to use International Law or Necessity as a defense. I was able to mention it above because this statement was given after I was pronounced guilty. I requested a sentence of service with Mennonite Disaster Service helping rebuild after the hurricanes. Instead, Judge G. Mallon Faircloth sentenced me to 3 months in Federal Prison and a $500. fine.]
On November 20, 2005 I joined more than 19,000 fellow citizens at the entrance of Fort Benning in Columbus, GA, adding my voice to the growing chorus calling for the closure of “The Western Hemisphere Institute for Security Cooperation” (WHINSEC) aka “School of the Americas” (SOA). This peaceful/prayerful witness has been taking place in November for the past 15 years to coincide with the anniversary of the martyrdom of six Jesuit priests, their housekeeper and her daughter in San Salvador in 1989. The U.N. Truth Commission set up after El Salvador’s long, bloody civil war concluded that responsibility for the assassinations of these people of faith (as well as countless others) was directed and carried out by military personnel who had been trained at the SOA before committing these murders of unarmed advocates for justice.
I had the opportunity to travel to El Salvador this past March to be present for the national recognition of the 25th anniversary of the martyrdom/assassination of the Archbishop of El Salvador, Oscar Romero. I had read several books that have been written about his life, collections of his sermons and pastoral letters, and had viewed the motion picture released about his life and death. The love of the common people for his life and witness in El Salvador gives evidence that he has become a patron saint for the church in that small Central American nation. His murder has also been determined to have been ordered by a graduate of the SOA.
The group I joined also made a pilgrimage to two other sites during our week in El Salvador besides the places where Romero and the Jesuits were killed. We traveled to the chapel in the countryside built on the site where the bodies of three nuns and a lay religious worker were hastily buried after their rape and murders in December 1989. Again, the murders and human rights abuses to Jean Donovan, Maura Clark, Ita Ford, and Dorothy Kazel were linked to graduates of this school. I prayed for forgiveness for our complicity as citizens of the nation that trained and paid for their killers. We also were blessed to spend time with the survivors of the massacre of Copapayo, a small village outside of Suchitoto. After visiting the site of the original village and the ravine/lake shoreline where more than 150 were gunned down by the Salvadoran military, we were invited to visit their new village up-lake from there to share a meal with some of the survivors. Again, these murders of the peasants was directed by, and carried out by, SOA graduates. I went to the annual vigil this year to honor their memories.
This year was the 12th year in a row that I was able to attend the annual vigil sponsored by the School of the Americas Watch. I was blessed to be able to travel and be present with members of my faith community, the Community of St. Martin, as well as my youngest son, Zach. He is morally and politically opposed to this present war and I wanted to show him that there are nonviolent ways to take a stand in the hope that he too will embrace nonviolence as a way to refuse to participate in the oppression of others. It is my hope that he is on his own journey to become a conscientious objector to the violence in our world.
As the annual litany of names of the thousands killed in Central and South America by SOA graduates was sung in the prayerful, solemn memorial remembrance, it was my intent to carry a small cross painted with the name of Monsignor Oscar Romero on to the military base and to walk toward the location of this school of torture and assassination. It was my intent to “give legs” to my prayers for peace and an end to the violent oppression that this school symbolizes. Although I was arrested by military police before I was able to reach the SOA buildings I attempted to walk as far as I was able, each step a prayer for both the victims and the perpetrators, for our governmental leaders and all of us taxpayers who are complicit in the on-going crimes committed by the product of this institution.
I came to pray for the victims of the SOA and an end to the policy that “winks” at the violations of human rights and seeks to parse the word “torture” in order to continue its use. I came to pray for forgiveness for my own complicity as a citizen of this nation which has chosen to use military force and intimidation to secure and use a disproportionate amount of the world’s resources in the face of poverty and repression of other peoples. I have committed myself to attempt to walk in the way of nonviolence as lived and taught by Jesus of Nazareth.
I do not view my act of conscience as a criminal act. Under the U.S. Constitution, Article 6, known as the “Supremacy Clause”, U.S. citizens are informed that any treaties entered into by our government become the supreme law of the land and all judges are bound by them. When the United States signed the treaty to become a member of the United Nations, the language of that treaty contained the language of the Principles of the Nuremberg Tribunal. The last of those seven principles states that “complicity with the commission of a war crime, a crime against peace, and a crime against humanity is a violation of International Law.” Respectfully, I remind the Court that German judges were prosecuted by the Nuremberg Tribunals.
The U.S. Government as a signatory to the Convention Against Torture and the Universal Declaration of Human Rights has legally committed itself to forgo the activities I believe have been taught and encouraged by The School of the Americas and its successor, WHINSEC. As such, I feel I have a moral and legal obligation under the Nuremberg Principles not to be complicit by remaining silent in the face of the atrocities committed by graduates of this military school which has promoted torture, rape, assassination, and repression of progressive peoples in Latin America over the years. I urge our national leaders to live up to both the letter and the spirit of the treaties it has not only signed but helped write. Amnesty International USA has also called for an investigation of this school.
The SOA/WHINSEC is a symbol of our national foreign policy which has led to the tortures of Iraqis at Abu Ghraib and many other prisons in Iraq, Afghanistan, Guantanamo, and many secret locations run by the CIA around the world under the misguided aim to quell “terrorism” by violence and intimidation in order that the “beneficiaries” of the American Empire can continue a standard of living at the expense of the world’s poor. The SOA continues to train military officers of Colombia who have been implicated in human rights abuses.
I went to Fort Benning and the SOA confessing my own failure to more fully follow the life and teaching of Jesus who calls us to a lifestyle of justice and compassion. My prayers and act of civil resistance to these powers of death are a small attempt to give a voice to the voiceless, to speak and act in solidarity with the victims of our national policies which are embodied in this institution which has produced so much evil over the years. I pray that this saying “NO” to the powers of death is swallowed up in the “YES” embodied in the life and teaching of Jesus and I will continue to work for a world of justice, compassion, and equal opportunity. I ask all of you to join me as you are able to work and pray to close this school and change our policy.
I wish to end on a personal note. On Monday I was seated in the rear of the courtroom in support of my friend Sam Foster. Prior to the beginning of the trials, the Court Officer/Bailiff told us, “Act like you’re in church”, informing us of the behavior he expected of those of us observing the trials. I’ve taken his instruction to heart.
Although the Court has framed this issue before us as a political one – the law does not permit “political demonstrations on a military facility”, for me, this is primarily a theological issue.
I know this is dangerous ground because much of the worst excesses in recent history have been the result of some people acting because “God (or Allah) told me to.”
For me, as one who has chosen to follow the way of a nonviolent Jesus, I resonate with the response in Christian scripture attributed to the disciples Peter and John when a conflict arose: “We must obey God rather than human authority.”
I gladly submit to whatever punishment the Court wishes to impose but wish to make it clear that my presence on the military base on November 20 was a theological statement that this precious earth entrusted to us by our Creator is not to be used to prepare for war and domination of others but rather to embrace all of life as God’s gift.
For my sentence I suggest a period of service with the Mennonite Disaster Service in the clean-up and rebuilding of areas destroyed by recent hurricanes in the southern states in lieu of sending me to prison; I will gladly make a monetary contribution to that organization in lieu of paying a fine. I am a Mennonite and a pacifist- any fine levied by the court is a tax upon my conscience and a violation of the promises given to my ancestors in 1705 when they were recruited by William Penn to help populate the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania.
[I entered a plea of Nolo Contendre (no contest) because the Judge previously ruled before trial we were not allowed to use International Law or Necessity as a defense. I was able to mention it above because this statement was given after I was pronounced guilty. I requested a sentence of service with Mennonite Disaster Service helping rebuild after the hurricanes. Instead, Judge G. Mallon Faircloth sentenced me to 3 months in Federal Prison and a $500. fine.]
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)